When it comes to the United States, Canadians can’t seem to make up their minds. For some, America is a close ally, a cultural powerhouse, and a necessary trading partner. For others, America is the enemy—a nation whose politics, policies, and global behavior cause frustration or outright resentment.
This division isn’t new, but it has deepened in recent years. Whether it’s due to American foreign policy, domestic issues that bleed north, or the cultural influence of the U.S., the Canadian relationship with America is anything but simple.
Why Some Canadians Say “America is the Enemy”
The phrase may sound dramatic, but it captures a real sentiment. Here’s why some Canadians lean into the idea that America is the enemy:
- U.S. Politics: The last decade of divisive American politics has left many Canadians disillusioned. From Trump-era rhetoric to ongoing debates about gun control and reproductive rights, Canadians often view U.S. political discourse as chaotic and extreme.
- Cultural Influence: American media dominates Canadian airwaves. While some embrace it, others feel it erodes Canadian identity and values. It’s not uncommon to hear concerns that Canadian stories are getting drowned out by louder voices from the south.
- Global Actions: Whether it’s military interventions or trade disputes, many Canadians criticize America’s role on the world stage. The U.S. is often viewed as a bully, using its power without enough regard for consequences.
But It’s Complicated: The Other Side of the Coin
Not all Canadians see the U.S. as the enemy. In fact, many have a deep appreciation for American innovation, culture, and history.
- Economic Ties: The U.S. is Canada’s largest trading partner. Millions of jobs on both sides of the border rely on a healthy economic relationship.
- Shared Values: Despite differences, both countries share commitments to democracy, freedom of speech, and the rule of law. This shared foundation still matters to many.
- Travel and Family Ties: Many Canadians travel to or live in the U.S. The countries are connected through families, friendships, and business relationships that transcend politics.
Where Canadians Go From Here
The divide over whether America is the enemy isn’t going away. It reflects deeper questions about national identity, sovereignty, and values. For Canadians, it’s less about hating their neighbor and more about wrestling with what kind of relationship they want to have.
Some will keep criticizing the U.S. loudly. Others will keep crossing the border to shop, study, and visit. Most will do both—because, like any long-term relationship, the one between Canada and the United States is layered, messy, and hard to label.
In the end, America isn’t strictly the enemy or the hero. It’s just the neighbor next door—and like most neighbors, Canadians have strong opinions about what goes on across the fence.
